Winter in the workshop: what cold really does to a phone, and what it doesn't

Winter in the workshop: what cold really does to a phone, and what it doesn't

From November onwards the work on the bench changes. Not because the devices are different, but because cold brings complaints to the surface that barely exist in July: a device that shuts down outside while there is still charge left, a screen that stops cooperating for a while, a connector that suddenly reports moisture.

The useful distinction: what cold does temporarily, and what stays permanent. That decides whether you replace something or explain something.

What cold does temporarily

Inside a lithium-ion cell, lithium ions have to travel through the electrolyte from one side to the other. The colder it gets, the worse that material conducts those ions and the higher the internal resistance climbs. The result is less usable capacity and a voltage that sags further under load.

The NIPV, the Dutch institute for public safety, writes that the capacity loss during discharge in the cold is in principle reversible as soon as the battery comes back to around twenty degrees. Apple says the same about its devices: cold conditions shorten runtime temporarily, and once the device is back inside its normal range, performance returns to normal. Apple gives 0 to 35 degrees as the range in which an iPhone works best, with 16 to 22 degrees as the ideal zone and -20 to 45 degrees for storage. Samsung lists the same operating range of 0 to 35 degrees for Galaxy devices.

So a device that shuts down outside at four degrees and switches on normally half an hour later indoors does not have a fault. That is physics.

What sits underneath it is something else: cold is a test. A voltage dip under load is absorbed by a healthy battery, not by a battery with years on it. A device that got through three winters without trouble and now shuts down at the first night frost almost always has a worn battery — the cold has only brought it to light. That is a different conversation with the customer than “it’s the cold, that’s normal”.

What is genuinely permanent: charging below freezing

This is where the real damage sits, and it is invisible.

Battery University holds a charge range of 0 to 45 degrees for ordinary lithium-ion cells, against a discharge range of -20 to 60 degrees. Below five degrees the charge current already has to come down, and below freezing charging is not permitted. The reason is that the ions cannot be taken into the anode fast enough. The battery appears to charge normally, but part of the lithium deposits as metal on the surface of the anode. This is called lithium plating, and it does not go away.

The NIPV describes what can happen next: that metallic lithium can grow into dendrites, which can grow through the separator and in extreme cases cause an internal short circuit. The higher the charge current, the more plating. In one of the experiments cited, the achievable state of charge was 7 to 23 per cent lower between -5 and -15 degrees.

For a phone in a coat pocket this is usually not a problem, because the manufacturer has closed it off. Apple pauses charging at extreme temperatures and, since iOS 16, shows a lock screen notification when that happens. Samsung writes that charging is limited to protect the battery as soon as the temperature falls outside a certain range. That is not a fault — that is the protection doing its job.

The problem sits wherever that protection is absent, or in an environment colder than the battery can take: loose batteries and power banks put on the charger in a cold van or an unheated shed, and stock in a room that drops below freezing overnight. For a workshop that is a practical lesson: don't keep stock in the coldest corner, and let a battery that has come in from outside acclimatise before you connect it or measure it.

Condensation: the damage you don't see coming

A device that has been outside for an hour is the coldest object in a warm room. Moisture from the air settles on it, and not only on the outside: it also gets into the connector and in along the seams. The same chemistry as water damage, just in smaller amounts and more often.

The best response is to force nothing. For the moisture alert on the connector Apple writes: unplug the cable, tap the device gently with the connector facing down, then leave it for at least thirty minutes in a dry place with airflow. If the alert keeps coming back, drying can take up to twenty-four hours. Not to be done: an external heat source, compressed air, a cotton swab in the connector, or a bag of rice — grains of rice in a USB-C connector are a second problem, not a solution.

The screen that stops cooperating

Cold also slows down the panel itself. The best known example is the iPhone X: in November 2017 that screen stopped responding to touch during a sudden drop in temperature, which Apple acknowledged and fixed in iOS 11.1.2.

A screen that is slow in the cold and works normally indoors at room temperature is therefore not a faulty panel. Let it warm up first, then judge — you don't want to have ordered a panel for that.

What you do with it

In short: discharging in the cold is temporary, charging in the cold is permanent, and condensation is the risk you can actually do something about.

What you pass on to a customer is therefore simple. Let an ice-cold device come back to room temperature before you put it on the charger, and not on the radiator. If it shuts down while the charge level is still high, have the battery measured.

In our courses, working safely with batteries is there from day one, and measuring before you replace is part of that: the difference between a battery that is cold and a battery that is worn out cannot be seen from the outside.

Learn the trade

From reading to doing

Everything this article talks about is something you learn with us in practice, with an instructor next to you who has done the job for years.